Sgt Peffer’s Cafe Italian Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Sgt Peffer’s Cafe Italian, where every meal feels like a celebration! Nestled in Omaha, this lively eatery specializes in a delightful array of authentic Italian dishes, all designed to tantalize your taste buds.
Start with the homemade sourdough rolls for just 99 cents, paired with their signature Cheezy Loaves, a cheesy delight elevated by a secret blend of spices. The heart of the menu features award-winning pizzas, including the Fab 4 and the hearty New Yorker. Each pie bursts with flavors, crafted with a passion for traditional ingredients and bold combinations.
Vegetarians will rejoice in options like the Gourmet Veg pizza, while meat lovers can indulge in the Italian Joe sandwich, perfect for lunch or sharing with friends. With a vibrant atmosphere, outdoor seating, and caring staff, Sgt Peffer’s Cafe is your go-to destination for casual dining and memorable meals!
Sandwiches
Roast Beef Au Jus
Add onions and/or peppers, no extra charge
Meatloaf Deli
Our cool Italian meatloaf on an Italian sub roll with zesty dijon mayo.
Ham Deli
Ham and Swiss cheese.
Turkey Deli
Turkey and Swiss cheese.
Club Sub Deli
Turkey, ham, and Swiss cheese.
Yellow Submarine Deli
A cool deli combination of prosciutto, ham, and salami with choice of cheese.
Tuna Salad Deli
Albacore tuna, green onions, tomatoes with vinaigrette and Romano cheese on an Italian hoagie.
Grilled Chicken Deli
Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, and dijon vinaigrette.
Meatball
A toasted hoagie bun topped with meatballs, tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella.
Italian Sausage
Our best seller gigantic sausage with mancini peppers and mozzarella.
Sargento
Salami, pepperoni, and melted Swiss on a baked bun.
Italian Joe
Florentine version of the sloppy. Homemade roll halved and smothered with bolognese, melted mozzarella, and Romano, then baked.
Super Joe
The Italian Joe with sliced grilled Italian sausage and mancini peppers, served toasted open faced.
Hot Strombo
Baked bun stuffed with sliced ham, pepperoni, mancini peppers, mozzarella, and Romano.
Turkey, Bacon & Swiss
Topped with dijon mayo, tomato, lettuce, and onion.
Combination - Sgt Peffers Specialties
Pepperoni, beef, fresh mushrooms, olives, onions. No substitutions please. Let it be.
The Fab 4 - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Prosciutto, black olives artichokes, marinated mushrooms. No substitutions please. Let it be.
Veggy
Fresh tomato, fresh mushrooms, onions, olives, green peppers, zukes. No substitutions please. Let it be.
Marinara - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Shrimp, clams, crab, tuna. No substitutions please. Let it be.
5 Cheese White - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Provolone, Parmesan, cheddar, mozzarella, Romano cheese on our creamy alfredo sauce. No substitutions please. Let it be.
5 Cheese Red - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Provolone, Parmesan, cheddar, mozzarella, Romano cheese on pomarola sauce. No substitutions please. Let it be.
New Yorker - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Italian sausage, anchovy, fresh mushrooms, pepperoni, meatballs, green pepper, onions, olives, mozzarella, Romano, and Parmesan cheese. No substitutions please. Let it be.
BLT - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Bacon, fresh tomato, mozzarella, and our alfredo sauce covered with fresh shredded lettuce. No substitutions please. Let it be.
White Surf - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Albacore tuna, shrimp, crab, clams, mozzarella, Romano, and our alfredo sauce. No substitutions please. Let it be.
Gourmet Veg - Sgt Peffer's Specialties
Broccoli, eggplant, spinach, sundried tomato, fresh mushrooms, and onions. No substitutions please. Let it be.
Prime Cut
Spicy. American and Italian sausages, beef, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, and smoked bacon. No substitutions please. Let it be.
Sgt Peffer's Authentic - Award Winning Pizza
Appetizers
Homemade Sourdough Rolls
Whole honey wheat while they last.
Cheezy Loaves
Cheesy pizza bites topped with mozzarella cheese and our secret blend of spices. comes with sides of our homemade pomarola sauce.
Pepperoni Pizza Bread
Bread topped with sauce and cheese.
Combo Pizza Bread
Bread topped with sauce and cheese. a meal that combines various types of food or drinks.
BBQ Meatballs (12)
12 pieces.
BBQ Wings (12)
12 pieces.
Mozzarella Sticks
Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried.
Italian Sausage Chunks & Peppers
Gluten-free.
Meatball Chunks & Pomarola
Ball of seasoned meat.
Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken breast marinated, grilled and sliced thin, mixed with marinated mushrooms, artichoke hearts, black olives, and fresh parsley covered with dijon vinaigrette. Served on spinach and lettuce greens.
Italian Tuna Salad
Albacore tuna, green onions, celery, red peppers, and tomato served on a bed of spinach and lettuce.
Spinach Salad
Fresh spinach greens with mushrooms, black olives, and provolone.
Dinner Salad
Iceberg lettuce with an assortment of veggies and your choice of dressing.
Italian Chef Salad
Spinach and iceberg lettuce with prosciutto, artichokes, tomatoes, olives, mushrooms provolone and Parmesan cheese.
American Chef
Spinach and lettuce topped with ham, turkey, tomato, onions, olives, mushrooms, cheddar and broccoli.
Stuffed Tomato (Seasonal)
Fresh tomato sliced open and stuffed with either grilled chicken or tuna salad. Served on lettuce and spinach.
Homemade Soup of the Day
Minestrone everyday and a special soup du jour.
Gourmet Salads & Award Winning Soups
Ala Carte
Bowl of Today's Homemade Soup (Monday)
Minestrone served everyday.
Bowl of Today's Homemade Soup (Tuesday)
Minestrone served everyday.
Bowl of Today's Homemade Soup (Wednesday)
Minestrone served everyday.
Bowl of Today's Homemade Soup (Thursday)
Minestrone served everyday.
Bowl of Today's Homemade Soup (Friday)
Minestrone served everyday.
Bowl of Today's Homemade Soup (Saturday & Sunday)
Minestrone served everyday.
Chicken Quattroformaggi
A blend of four cheeses, cream, and black pepper.
Chicken Cacciatore
Green and red bell peppers, garlic, mushrooms, and sage sautéed in olive oil simmered in pomarola.
Butter Garlic Chicken
Baked with butter, garlic, and seasoning.
Mancini Chicken
Roasted peppers, pomarola, Parmesan, and mozzarella.
Sherry Cream Mushroom Chicken
Mushrooms, creamed burgundy, and Parmesan.
Chicken Parmesan
Pomarola, mozzarella, and Parmesan.
Chicken Milano
Broccoli, mushrooms, onions, garlic with creamy alfredo.
Creamy Chicken Alfredo
Heavy cream, Parmesan cheese, and black pepper.
Baked Chicken Casseroles
Baked Seafood Casseroles
Baked Scampi
Shrimp, butter garlic and Parmesan baked on linguini.
Scampi & Artichokes
Gluten free. Artichoke hearts, shrimp and Parmesan tossed with our butter garlic on linguini.
Albacore Boscaiolla
Pure white tuna, sweet peas, marinated mushrooms and creamy Parmesan sauce.
Quattroformaggi Fillet
Baked whitefish with four cheese sauce on linguini.
Butter Garlic Fillet
Gluten free. Creamy butter, minced garlic and basil on linguini.
Seafood Lasagna
Shrimp and crab layered with ricotta, Parmesan, mozzarella and creamy afredo sauce.
Ricotta Tortellini & Shrimp
Heavy cream, Parmesan cheese and black pepper.
Lasagna
Beef, pork, sautéed vegetables with ricotta, Parmesan, mozzarella and provolone.
Vegetarian Lasagna
Our red mushroom sauce with ricotta, spinach, provolone, mozzarella and Parmesan cheeses.
Mannicotti
Ricotta and Parmesan cheese stuffed in a pasta tube and topped with our pomarola or alfredo sauce.
Canelloni
Blend of beef, pork, spices stuffed in a pasta tube and topped with our pomarola or alfredo sauce.
Grilled Chicken & Artichoke Lasagna
Lasagna with ricotta, Parmesan, mozarella, provolone cheeses, fresh basil with red or alfredo sauce.
Ravioli
Beef or cheese ravioli with eith pomarola or alfredo sauce.
Tortellini
Beef or cheese Stuffed tortes with either pomarola or alfredo Sauce.
Variety Tortellini
Cheese stuffed tri-colored tortellini with pomarola or alfredo sauce.
Stuffed Red Bell Peppers
Halved red bell peppers stuffed with rice, Italian sausage, aged cheeses and poarola sauce.
Stuffed Red Bell Peppers with Alfredo Sauce
Halved red bell peppers stuffed with rice, Italian sausage, aged cheeses and alfredo sauce (not gluten friendly).
Baked Pasta
Creative Pasta
Creamy Clam (Sgt Peffer's Signature Pasta)
Clams and creamy parmesan sauce.
Alfredo (Sgt Peffer's Signature Pasta)
Heavy cream, Parmesan, black pepper and parsley.
Quattroformaggi (Sgt Peffer's Signature Pasta)
Quatro-for-mah-zhay. Creamy sauce of bleu cheese, Parmesan, provolone and Romano with a dash of black pepper.
Sherry Cream Mushroom (Sgt Peffer's Signature Pasta)
Fresh mushrooms sautéed with basil, thyme and pepper then simmered in burgundy, cream and Parmesan.
Boscalolla (Sgt Peffer's Signature Pasta)
Boss kay yola, prosciutto with sweet peas, marinated mushrooms and creamy parmesan sauce (best on linguini).
Pomarola & Meatballs (Sgt Peffer's Classics)
Our homemade red sauce with crushed tomatoes, olive oil and basil and two homemade meatballs. Substitute grilled Italian sausage.
Bolognese (Sgt Peffer's Classics)
Sausage and beef with vegetables sautéed in olive oil red with crushed tomatoes and Romano cheese.
Red Mushroom (Sgt Peffer's Classics)
Gluten free. Fresh mushrooms simmered with onions, fresh parsley, thyme pepper and pomarola.
Red Clam (Sgt Peffer's Classics)
Gluten free. Clams sautéed in olive oil red and black pepper, fresh parsley then simmered with pomarola.
White Clam (Sgt Peffer's Classics)
Clams sautéed with parsley, pepper in olive oil simmered in clear clam juice.
Pesto (Sgt Peffer's Classics)
Olive oil, pine nuts, Parmesan cheese, basil and garlic.
Red Mushroom
Gluten free. fresh mushrooms simmered with onions, fresh parsley. thyme, pepper and pomarola.
Bolognese
Gluten free. sausage and beef with vegetables sautéed in olive oil simmered with crushed tomatoes and romano cheese.
Alfredo
Heavy cream, parmesan, black pepper and parsley.
Sherry Cream Mushroom
Fresh mushrooms sautéed with basil, thyme and pepper then simmered in burgundy, cream and parmesan.
Meatballs
A toasted hoagie bun topped with meatballs tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.